论点1:(正方)不人道First of all,the main disadvantage of animal testing is the inhumane treatment of animals in tests due to the fact that anesthesia for the help of pain is often not used、Scientists say that
using anesthesia will interfere with test results、Today the term
is used、Vivisection is defined as “cutting while still “vivisection”
alive” but it is more commonly used today as any harmful experiment
or test that is performed on an animal、Animal experimentation
involves the incarceration of animals and poisoning, mutilation,
disease and killing of those individuals、It is arguably the most brutal
and most severe form of violence in the modern world、It is said that
an estimated 50,000 animals die due to the testing on them、Some of
the tests that IAMS performed were:
28 female cats had their abdomens(腹部) cut open and solution
injected repeatedly into their bowels、
24 young dogs were given kidney failure by the removal of one
kidney and the damaging of the other、All the dogs were killed
after being fed an experimental diet and their kidneys analyzed、论点2:(正方)可有别的措施Many alternatives already exist, and there
race实验must be many more which are waiting to be found、The day will
surely come when not more experiments on animals will need to be
done for human medicine、it's hared to say there will always be alternatives for veterinary research, The most common alternatives
that are used today are: in-vitro tests, computer software, and even
、The use of animal cells, organs, and tissue human “clinical tests”
cultures are also deemed as alternatives,
(反驳正方)however animal lives are still sacrificed for the use of their parts、We can only talk about banning experimentation when the alternatives have been proved to be accurate, and safe、
→ (反方反驳)As a medical student, I've realized that artificial means can never replace the incredible complexity of living animals、It may not be possible to ban all animal tests quite yet, but there should be a lot more money, time
and efforts going into finding alternatives、
新论点3：正方：动物也有权利Could anyone tell me why humans are more important than any other animals? Could anyone please tell me the fundamental reason why human suffering is 'absolutely' more important than animal suffering, why the intense agony experienced
by a laboratory animal is inconsequential(不重要的，微不足道的) when view against the same or even lesser degree of suffering within
a human、Of course We see ourselves as more important than other species, as I'm sure other self-realising species see themselves, but we cannot use this flimsy(轻而薄的), subjective(主观上的) argument as an excuse to totally disregard the feelings of other species、You wouldn't like it if some alien race claiming to be the most "important" turned up and squirted alien cosmetics in your mother's eye, would you? So I think animals should have the same rights as us、You wouldn't like it if people were doing any kind of experiment on you、Humankind has absolutely no right to use animals for any reason whatsoever, especially for experimental use、
新论点4正方类比种族We conduct such experiments simply because we have physical dominance over all other species and thus we can exploit them at our will、But then where lies the contradiction between this form exploitation and that shown within the human species, such as the physical dominance that allowed Europeans to exploit Africans in the slave trade、Why should I be utterly indifferent to animal suffering because I stand to gain from it, yet I
am morally obliged to be passionate about human suffering whether
or not it could be for my personal betterment、
新论点5：正方动物实验有时候真的没有必要、I understand the concerns
over medical testing and "human needs over animal lives", but the testing obviously doesn't work because there is still AIDS, cancer and all the other diseases that these tests are supposed to be curing、If medical tests really are needed, why can't there be a more humane way to do it? Why not use people's cells, skin etc、Human volunteers should be used for final testing rather than animals、
最后总结(正方)All in all, the animals can not tell the scientist that
、We need to talk for they don’t want to be tested on, but humans can
the animals and help stop this cruel and inhumane treatment、There are many other ways that products and medicine can be tested; the use of innocent animals is no longer needed、Let us turn down cures that have been tested on animals、Thank you、
反方
开场:For those opposed to all animal testing, please answer 'Yes' or 'No' to the following questions
1、Are you vegetarian?
2、Do you avoid buying leather shoes or clothes?
3、Would you allow yourself or a loved one to suffer or even die because the necessary treatment had been developed using laboratory animals?
If you answered 'Yes' to ALL of the above, then you are free from
hypocrisy(伪善，虚伪) in your moral stance(l立场姿态)、
论点1：我们需要动物实验Animals testing is really necessary、
分论点(1)患者的需要First of all , all the patients are in the need of the testing、Why? Could you realize that the animals you believe are being harmed, have not only impacted your lives in some way, but have impacted your families, friends, by providing people with vaccines and antibiotics、When it comes down to it, rightly or wrongly, we will all happily sacrifice an animal in order to save a loved one! Millions of lives are saved every year because of one
r a drug or new form of surgery、Tell me that animal’s, results to eithe
Which would you prefer to live - an ill child or a healthy bunny? With rights come responsibilities - what responsibilities to animals have? How many people who advocate banning animal testing have accepted medicines which have almost surely been tested on animals、 A move towards animal rig
hts means a move away from human rights、
分论点(2)科学研究的需要The second, a nimal testing is the most predominant form of testing used by scientists、Animal research plays a vital, and irreplaceable, role in such fields as drug and cancer research、The phase of research on animals gave us essential data which moved us on、The knowledge so gained is being used to provide more effective treatment for seriously disabled humans、The
豫公网安备41160202000603
站长QQ:729038198
关于我们
投诉建议